Authors: Marije C. Koelé, Hanna C. Willems, Karin M. A. Swart, Suzanne C. van Dijk, Paul Lips, Lisette C. P. G. M. de Groot, Tischa J. M. van der Cammen, M. Carola Zillikens, Natasja M. van Schoor, Nathalie van der Velde
Categories: Original Article, Fall incidence, Falls, Kyphosis
Source: Osteoporosis International
Authors: Marije C. Koelé, Hanna C. Willems, Karin M. A. Swart, Suzanne C. van Dijk, Paul Lips, Lisette C. P. G. M. de Groot, Tischa J. M. van der Cammen, M. Carola Zillikens, Natasja M. van Schoor, Nathalie van der Velde
Hyperkyphosis, an increased kyphosis angle of the thoracic spine, was associated with a higher fall incidence in the oldest quartile of a large prospective cohort of community-dwelling older adults. Hyperkyphosis could serve as an indicator of an increased fall risk as well as a treatable condition.
Hyperkyphosis is frequently found in adults aged 65 years and older and may be associated with falls. We aimed to investigate prospectively in community-dwelling older adults whether hyperkyphosis or change in the kyphosis angle is associated with fall incidence.
Community-dwelling older adults (n = 1220, mean age 72.9 ± 5.7 years) reported falls weekly over 2 years. We measured thoracic kyphosis through the Cobb angle between the fourth and 12th thoracic vertebra on DXA-based vertebral fracture assessments and defined hyperkyphosis as a Cobb angle ≥ 50°. The change in the Cobb angle during follow-up was dichotomized (< 5 or ≥ 5°). Through multifactorial regression analysis, we investigated the association between the kyphosis angle and falls.
Hyperkyphosis was present in 15% of the participants. During follow-up, 48% of the participants fell at least once. In the total study population, hyperkyphosis was not associated with the number of falls (adjusted IRR 1.12, 95% CI 0.91–1.39). We observed effect modification by age (p = 0.002). In the oldest quartile, aged 77 years and older, hyperkyphosis was prospectively associated with a higher number of falls (adjusted IRR 1.67, 95% CI 1.14–2.45). Change in the kyphosis angle was not associated with fall incidence.
Hyperkyphosis was associated with a higher fall incidence in the oldest quartile of a large prospective cohort of community-dwelling older adults. Because hyperkyphosis is a partially reversible condition, we recommend investigating whether hyperkyphosis is one of the causes of falls and whether a decrease in the kyphosis angle may contribute to fall prevention.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00198-021-06136-6.
The incidence of falls is high among older one out of three adults aged 65 years and older experiences one or more falls annually [1–3]. Serious injuries occur in one out of five fall incidents [3], with negative consequences for both the individual patient and society. In the individual patient, downregulation of activities due to fear of falling causes deconditioning [4, 5]. Deconditioning increases fall risk, resulting in a lower quality of life [6, 7]. Furthermore, patients live three times more often in a nursing home after hospitalization due to fall-related injury than to a non-fall-related reason [6]. Society bears the high medical costs of hospitalization and other medical care needed after a fall incident [7, 8]. As fall rates and accompanying medical costs have been rising worldwide over the past decade [7–9], identifying fall risk factors is important in order to minimize the number of fall incidents and thereby their negative consequences.
One of the most important fall risk factors is a balance disorder [10]. Balance may be influenced by thoracic hyperkyphosis, an excessive curvature of the thoracic spine. Hyperkyphosis may shift the center of mass of the body forward if compensation in the lumbar spine and hip region is not sufficient and thereby cause gait disorders and disruption of balance [11–13]. Hyperkyphosis is frequently found in older adults [14]. However, conflicting results regarding the association between hyperkyphosis and fall risk are reported [15–22]. The only large prospective study on this association recently showed that in older men a larger kyphosis angle, measured with the blocks method, was associated to fall risk (RR = 1.12, 95% CI = 1.06, 1.18), yet a larger Cobb angle was not associated to fall risk [23]. The Cobb angle, the angle between two thoracic vertebra on a lateral radiograph in standing position [24], has been used extensively in literature to measure the kyphosis angle [14]. More prospective studies are warranted in both men and women using the Cobb angle, to investigate whether a larger kyphosis angle is associated with fall incidents over time.
We hypothesized that hyperkyphosis, measured with the Cobb angle (Fig. 1), will be prospectively associated to an increased fall incidence in a large cohort of older adults.Fig. 1Cobb angle
Whether change in kyphosis over time influences fall risk has not yet been investigated. Change in the kyphosis angle over time may alter the body’s center of mass that could negatively impact balance and increase fall risk. Adapting to the change in the kyphosis angle may increase fall risk. We hypothesized therefore that change in the kyphosis angle over time will be associated to an increased fall risk.
The current study was performed within the sub-sample of the B-PROOF study in which a dual-energy X-ray assessment (DXA) was available (n = 1220). Only participants included in two of the three study centers underwent a DXA, because a DXA scanner was only present in these two study centers. The B-PROOF (B-vitamins for the Prevention of Osteoporotic Fractures) study is a multi-center randomized placebo-controlled double-blind intervention study aimed at investigating whether vitamin B12 and folic acid supplementation reduces osteoporotic fracture incidence in older individuals with an elevated homocysteine level. Inhabitants of the area of the research centers in the Netherlands were invited by mail to participate if they were 65 years or older. Participants were included from August 2008 until March 2011 if their plasma homocysteine level was ≥ 12 μmol/L. Renal function influences homocysteine levels. Therefore, participants were included if they had sufficient renal function (serum creatinine concentration ≤ 150 µmol/L). They were excluded if they reported malignancies in the past 5 years and if they were bedridden or wheelchair bound [25]. Because the supplementation of vitamin B12 and folic acid had no effect on osteoporotic fractures, fall incidence, or physical performance [26], we treated the study population of the original trial as a cohort in our current study. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.
The Cobb angle was first described to quantify scoliosis. By modifying the direction of radiographic imaging from anterior–posterior to lateral projection, the Cobb angle became useful to assess kyphosis angles [22]. Numerous kyphosis measurement methods have been used to quantify the kyphosis angle, both in standing and recumbent position [23, 27–29]. The Cobb angle is currently considered to be the gold standard kyphosis measurement when measured on standing radiographic images [14]. We measured the Cobb angle on the DXA-based vertebral fracture assessment (VFA), made in the recumbent position. In several studies, the Cobb angle has been applied in recumbent position [29–31]. Kado et al. and Tran et al. showed a reasonable correlation between the Cobb angle in recumbent position and kyphosis, measured in standing position (ICC 0.65–0.68), and a reasonable correlation (ICC 0.68) between two kyphosis measurement methods in recumbent position [32]. Yet this correlation may be lower with increasing kyphosis angles, as a correlation of 0.44 was reported in hyperkyphotic participants (Cobb angle ≥ 50º**)** [33]. We defined hyperkyphosis as a Cobb angle of ≥ 50° in order to compare our results with prior research [18, 27].
Two researchers (SK and IH) measured the Cobb angle independently. If the difference between the two measurements of the Cobb angle was less than 10°, we used the mean value. A third researcher (HW) remeasured the Cobb angle if the difference between the measurements was 10° or more or if the Cobb angle was judged to be more than 50° by one researcher and less than 50° by the other researcher. The third researcher remeasured 101 Cobb angles out of a total of 2,322 DXA scans (Cohen’s kappa 0.96): 53 because of a difference of more than 10° between the initial measurements of the two investigators, and the remaining 48 were remeasured because of different categorization of hyperkyphosis versus a normal kyphosis angle. Based on consensus, two researchers (HW and MK) decided the value of the final Cobb angle. In 1,102 participants, a DXA performed after 2 years of follow-up was available.
A fall was defined as “an unintentional change in position resulting in coming to rest at a lower level or on the ground.” Participants recorded falls prospectively on a research calendar every week. They returned the research calendar every 3 months. Participants were followed for 2 years after the baseline measurements. The primary outcome measure was the number of falls during follow-up [34].
We obtained age, gender, educational level, current alcohol intake, current or former smoking, use of a walking aid, medical history, and information on use of a walking aid and current medication use through structured questionnaires at baseline. We measured height, weight, and 25-hydroxy-vitamin-D concentration. Participants performed a timed tandem-stance test to assess balance. We measured for a maximum of 10 s how long participants were able to stand with one foot directly in front of the other with their eyes opened. Because of a ceiling effect, with 909 of the participants (75%) successfully standing in a tandem stance during the maximum duration of 10 s, we used categorized scores of the tandem-stance test. Scores ranged from 0 to 4 points (4, 10 s; 2, 4–9 s; 0, 4 s or less) and were categorized [35]. Hand-grip strength was measured with a strain-gauged dynamometer (Takei, TKK 5401, Takei Scientific Instruments Co. Ltd., Japan).
We compared baseline characteristics of the hyperkyphotic and the non-hyperkyphotic through a chi-square test for categorical and an independent Student’s t-test for continuous data. We used nonparametric tests if the distribution was skewed.
We performed a negative binomial regression analysis to test the association between number of falls and both hyperkyphosis and change in the kyphosis angle. Based on interrater reliability and intrarater reliability in the literature [36, 37], and our own cohorts (data not published) of 3.2–4.5°, we interpreted an increase in the Cobb angle of at least 5° during the follow-up as the minimal detectable difference. Five degrees of change has been shown to be associated with a decrease in physical performance and may therefore be clinically relevant [38]. We dichotomized change in the Cobb angle during follow-up to change (≥ 5°) or no change (< 5°).
The initial model only included hyperkyphosis and the number of falls. In this model, we tested for interaction with gender, because previous studies reported effect modification regarding the association between hyperkyphosis and fall risk [17, 21]. Based on a priori decisions, we also tested for interaction with age (oldest quartile vs. youngest 3 quartiles) and study center. If the p-value of interaction was 0.10 or below, we performed stratified analyses. In case of stratification, we compared relevant baseline characteristics between groups.
We tested for potential confounders by adding covariables separately to the initial model. If there was a change of ≥ 10% of the regression coefficient when adding a separate covariable, the covariable was considered to be a confounder and added to the adjusted model. We tested for confounding by age, gender, and study center if these variables were not effect modifiers. Furthermore, we tested for confounding by smoking, alcohol use, cardiovascular comorbidity, number of medications, use of a walking aid, and treatment allocation in the original trial.
In case of a statistically significant association between hyperkyphosis and number of falls, we assessed whether balance, hand-grip strength, and vitamin D concentration mediated this association. Balance is a potential mediator, because hyperkyphosis causes disruptions of balance and may therefore increase fall risk [11]. Multiple studies show an association between hyperkyphosis and decreased physical performance and even impairments in performance of activities of daily living [27], which may lead to physical inactivity and less exposure to sunlight. Through this pathway, muscle strength and vitamin D may also mediate the association between hyperkyphosis and falls.
We added these variables separately to the adjusted models, and if the incident rate ratio changed 10% or more, we considered the variable a mediator. Because osteoporosis is one of the causes of hyperkyphosis, we considered osteoporosis and the presence of one or more fractures as overlapping factors with hyperkyphosis. To avoid overadjustment, we did not adjust for these variables. The level of significance was set at α = 0.05. We performed statistical analyses with SPSS software, version 21.0.
Baseline characteristics are listed in Table 1. The mean age of the 1,220 participants was 72.9 ± 5.7 years. One-third of the participants reported a fall in the year before inclusion. During follow-up, 48% of participants had experienced one or more falls, and 25% were recurrent fallers. The median number of falls was one (interquartile range 0–2) in hyperkyphotic participants and zero (interquartile range 0–1) in participants with a normal kyphosis angle. Hyperkyphosis was present in 15% of the participants. The mean Cobb angle was 37.0° ± 11.9° in the total cohort, with a mean Cobb angle of 56.6° ± 6.4° in hyperkyphotic participants and 33.5° ± 8.9° in participants with a normal kyphosis angle. Participants with hyperkyphosis were older and more often female. Furthermore, they used a walking aid more often, had less hand-grip strength, and had a lower score on the balance test. Consistent with the fact that osteoporotic vertebral fractures cause hyperkyphosis, hyperkyphotic participants more often had vertebral fractures at baseline and clinical fractures after the age of 50 years. Although physical activity level was similar in both groups, the mean maximal hand-grip strength was lower for the hyperkyphotic group, which also more often had abnormal results in the balance test. In 22% (n = 240) of the participants with a VFA at follow-up, the increase in the Cobb angle was 5° or more. The mean change in the Cobb angle was 0.46° ± 5.7°.Table 1Baseline characteristicsCharacteristicHyperkyphosis (n = 188)No hyperkyphosis (n = 1032)pAge (years, SD)74.7 ± 6.372.5 ± 5.5** < .001Female (n, %)128 (68%)462 (45%) <** .001Education level (n, %)0.27 Low111 (59%)544 (53%) Intermediate35 (19%)209 (20%) High42 (22%)277 (27%) Current or former smoker (n, %)105 (56%)707 (69%)0.001Alcohol use ≥ 1 unit per day (n, %)49 (26%)388 (38%)0.002 Cardiovascular comorbidity (n, %)48 (27%)295 (31%)0.42 Number of medications (median, IQR)2.5 (1.0–4.0)3.0 (1.0–5.0)0.89 BMI [kg/m^2^] (mean, SD)27.0 ± 3.827.0 ± 3.90.83 MMSE-score (median, IQR)28 (27–29)28 (27–29)0.98 GDS-15-score (median, IQR)1 (0–2)1 (0–2)0.96 25-OH-vitamin D [ng/mL] (mean, SD)20.7 ± 8.822.3 ± 9.60.030Vertebral fractures ≥ 2 fractures present (n, %)20 (11%)66 (6%)0.034 Fracture after the age of 50 (n, %)59 (31%)228 (22%)0.006 Use of walking aid (n, %)23 (12%)66 (6%)0.005 Physical activity [min/day] (mean, SD)165 (102)160 (106)0.52 Hand-grip strength (mean, SD)29.0 ± 9.233.8 ± 10.2** < .001 Balance test abnormal (n, %)75 (40%)258 (25%) < .001 Cobb angle56.6° ± 6.4°33.5° ± 8.9° < **.001 Participants with ≥ 1 incident falls (n, %)97 (52%)492 (48%)0.322
Table 2 shows the association between falls and both hyperkyphosis at baseline and change in the kyphosis angle during follow-up. In the analyses regarding the association between hyperkyphosis and number of falls only, we observed effect modification by age (p = 0.002). We did not observe effect modification by gender or study center in any of the analyses.Table 2Results of the negative binomial regression analyses of the association between the number of falls and both hyperkyphosis and change in the kyphosis angleModel 1^a^ Ratio, 95% CIpModel 2 Ratio, 95% CIpHyperkyphosisIRR 1.15 (0.94–1.42)0.182IRR 1.12 (0.90–1.40)^b^0.31Oldest quartileIRR 1.53 (1.10–2.12)0.012IRR 1.67 (1.14–2.45)^b^0.008Youngest 3 quartilesIRR 0.87 (0.62–1.71)0.925IRR 0.91 (0.68–1.23)^b^0.55Change of kyphosisIRR 1.01 (0.98–1.03)0.654IRR 1.00 (0.98–1.03)^c^0.83^a^Unadjusted^b^Corrected for gender, cardiovascular comorbidity, and number of medications^C^Corrected for age and gender
In the adjusted analyses, hyperkyphosis was not associated with the number of falls, with an incident rate ratio (IRR) of 1.12 (95% CI 0.91–1.39, p = 0.291). Hyperkyphosis was significantly associated with a higher number of falls during follow-up in the oldest quartile of our cohort, aged 77 and older (IRR 1.53, 95% CI 1.10–2.12, p = 0.012). The oldest quartile more often had cardiovascular comorbidity, used more medications, and used a walking aid more often (all p < 0.001; Table 3). We tested for potential confounding by gender, smoking, alcohol use, treatment allocation, study center, use of a walking aid, cardiovascular comorbidity, and number of medications. Although the oldest quartile used a walking aid more often than the three younger quartiles, use of a walking aid was not a confounder. The covariables gender, smoking, alcohol use, treatment allocation, and study center were also no confounders. Only gender, cardiovascular comorbidity, and number of medications changed the regression coefficient ≥ 10% and were added to the model. In the adjusted analyses, the association persisted (IRR 1.67, 95% CI 1.14–2.45, p = 0.008).Table 3Differences in baseline characteristics between the oldest quartile, aged 77 years and older, and the youngest 3 quartilesCharacteristicOldest quartile (n = 314)Youngest three quartiles (n = 906)pAge (years, SD)80.6 ± 3.570.2 ± 3.3** < .001Female (n, %)149 (48%)441 (49%)0.71Cardiovascular comorbidity (n, %)102 (32%)241 (27%)0.001Number of medications (median, IQR)3 (1–5)2 (1–4) < .001Use of walking aid (n, %)59 (19%)30 (3%) < .001Physical activity [min/day] (mean, SD)140 (86)168 (110) < .001Hand-grip strength (mean, SD)29.5 ± 9.134.3 ± 10.3 <** .001Balance test abnormal (n, %)92 (29%)242 (27%)0.38
Balance, vitamin D concentration, and hand-grip strength did not mediate the association between hyperkyphosis and number of falls. Change in the kyphosis angle during the 2 years of follow-up was not associated with number of falls in the unadjusted and adjusted model (adjusted IRR 0.96, 95% CI 0.79–1.17, p = 0.689).
Hyperkyphosis was prospectively associated with a higher number of falls in the oldest quartile, aged 77 years and older, in a cohort of Dutch community-dwelling older adults. Change in the kyphosis angle was not associated with the number of falls during follow-up.
Most cross-sectional and in particular the 2 small prospective cohort studies reported a higher fall risk for hyperkyphotic participants [20, 23]. In our study, a significant association between hyperkyphosis and falls was only found in the oldest quartile, with a mean age of 80 years, a mean number of medications of 4, and cardiovascular comorbidity present in 32% (see supplement table S1). This is in concordance with current literature as both prospective studies assessed a comparable population. The cohort of van der Jagt-Willems consisted of geriatric outpatients with a mean age of 79 years, an average number of 6 medications, and an average Charlson Comorbidity Score of 1.3. McDaniels-Davidson included community-dwelling older adults as was the case in our cohort, though with a higher mean age of 78 years, 65% having more than 3 chronic conditions and an average number of 4 medications. This study and previous literature show that hyperkyphosis appears to form a fall risk factor in particularly the oldest age group, who have more comorbidities negatively affecting the compensatory mechanisms to prevent falls [11, 18, 19]. Generally, the number of fall risk factors increases with age. Among older adults, hyperkyphosis adds to a higher number of other fall risk factors and a decreased capability to prevent falls, resulting in an increased absolute fall risk.
Against the expectation, increase of the kyphosis angle was not associated with the number of falls during 2 years of follow-up. This may be explained by the low number of participants (n = 240) with an increase of the Cobb angle of ≥ 5°. Mean change of the Cobb angle in this cohort was 0.46° ± 5.7°. This is a small change compared to two previous studies, describing an increase of the Cobb angle 2.6° in 3 years and 7° in 15 years and 3.9 in 4 years [38, 39]. The follow-up duration of our study may have been too short to investigate this hypothesis.
We investigated potential contributory factors in the association between hyperkyphosis and falls. Previous literature showed that hyperkyphosis may disrupt balance [11] and, because balance disorders are a major fall risk factor, may therefore enhance fall risk. The current cohort study does not support this hypothesis, because performance on the balance test did not mediate the association between hyperkyphosis and number of falls. This is in line with other studies, reporting no association between hyperkyphosis and balance [13, 27, 40].
Apparently, literature is contradicting on the association between hyperkyphosis and balance. Yet, rather uniformly, sagittal inclination of the spine as a whole and the lumbar lordosis angle have been shown to be associated to impaired balance [13, 41] and a higher fall risk [18, 19, 41–43]. The Cobb angle is not always correlated to inclination of the total spine, as shown by Demarteau et al. and Katzman et al. in community-dwelling older adults [12, 13].
This may indicate that hyperkyphosis indeed influences balance and thereby fall risk, if it leads to a forward shift of the center of mass which cannot be compensated in the lumbosacral and hip region. The older adults participating in this study may have had enough ability to compensate a potential forward shift of the center of mass.
Another cause for not finding an effect of balance in our cohort may be that the sensitivity of the tandem-stance test may be limited. Using a more extensive balance test, such as the Berg Balance Scale, might lead to different results.
Another explanation for the higher fall incidence in older adults with hyperkyphosis may be muscle weakness. Muscle strength decreases with aging, and lower back-extensor-muscle strength and lower hand-grip strength is associated with a larger kyphosis angle [44] as well as with increased fall risk. However, although the adults aged 77 years and older had significantly lower hand-grip strength at baseline than the younger adults in our cohort (Table 3), we found no confounding or mediation by grip strength. Yet, in this study, we only measured hand-grip strength, which may be a suboptimal measure for muscle strength associated with hyperkyphosis compared to back-extensor-muscle strength.
The use of a walking aid may have influenced fall risk. Higher as well as lower fall risks among walking aid users have been described in literature. Twelve percent of the participants with hyperkyphosis reported using a walking aid versus 6% of the participants with a normal kyphosis angle. The use of a walking aid was no confounder regarding the association between hyperkyphosis and fall incidence. We have no evidence that the type of walking aid influenced the association between hyperkyphosis and the number of falls in this cohort.
Our cohort study has several strengths, including the prospective design with 2 years of prospective follow-up of the fall incidents and the large sample size. Furthermore, this study is the first to investigate the association between change in the kyphosis angle during follow-up and the fall incidence in older adults. Thus, we were able to detect potential temporary effects of a change in the kyphosis angle on the fall risk.
However, there are three limitations. First, we limited our analyses to the 1,220 participants of the cohort in whom a DXA was performed. The decision of whether a participant received a DXA scan was merely based on the availability of a DXA scanner in the study center. Potentially, we could have underestimated the association between hyperkyphosis and fall incidence by selecting participants who were fit enough to undergo the DXA scans. Secondly, the traditional gold standard kyphosis measurement is the Cobb angle, measured in standing position [14]. In our study, DEXA-based vertebral fracture assessments, made in recumbent position, were used. The posture of the participant during kyphosis measurement may influence the Cobb angle. The supine position eliminates the effects of gravity and the muscles and ligaments of the back, and the Cobb angle is expected to be smaller than in standing position, particularly among those with a greater degree of kyphosis [33].
Therefore, the use of DEXA-based vertebral fracture assessments, made in recumbent position, may have led to underestimation of the Cobb angle and the prevalence of hyperkyphosis in this cohort due to misclassification. The prevalence of hyperkyphosis in our study is indeed lower than in previous literature, in which prevalence ranges between 20 and 40% [14]. This may have led to underestimation of the association between hyperkyphosis and falls. Thirdly, all participants had a slightly elevated homocysteine level (median 14.4 (IQR 13.0–16.6) µmol/L), which may limit generalizability of study results. Nevertheless, we have no reason to assume a different association between hyperkyphosis and falls in normo-homocysteinic older adults compared to hyperhomocysteinic older adults, because the literature has reported no such difference. Additionally, in the general population, elevated homocysteine concentrations (≥ 15 µmol/L) are prevalent in 30 to 50% people aged 65 years and older [25] Treatment of the elevated homocysteine level did not affect fall risk or physical performance [26] In addition, treatment allocation was not a confounder in the analyses. Therefore, we think the homocysteine level is unlikely to have influenced the association between hyperkyphosis and fall incidence.
In conclusion, hyperkyphosis was associated with a higher number of falls in the adults aged 77 years and older of this first large prospective study in community-dwelling older adults. This association is of particular interest because hyperkyphosis is partially reversible [45]. Hyperkyphosis could serve as an indicator of an increased fall risk as well as a treatable condition in order to diminish the fall risk of an older adult with hyperkyphosis. Therefore, we recommend that future research investigate whether hyperkyphosis is one of the causes of falls and whether a decrease in the kyphosis angle contributes to fall prevention.
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.Supplementary file1 (DOCX 12.9 KB)